Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Weissman's avatar

I'm not sure I follow the argument about bad new variants arising especially in immuno-compromised individuals. Let's say that's right, reasonably. Wouldn't the number of those cases still scale approximately with the total number of infections? In that case, the selfish argument would still be correct. Since the people who it might reach probably exist, it seems strange to make a shaky case against it. It's not like it contradicts the argument from basic decency.

Expand full comment
Darij Grinberg's avatar

I think this is not about selfishness; it's about how far you (think you) have come with vaccinating your own country.

I'm not sure if it has fully filtered through into American society that the US has enough (non-AZ) jabs for every of its citizens. (In fact I'm keeping up with US news and I only learnt of this from you -- and even then I'm a tad doubtful. You are talking about doses in reserve or doses ordered? Is this sourced from the FDA, the CDC, the companies or the Biden admin?)

As a German, I was somewhat aggravated to read your previous post (for no fault of yours) -- Merkel and various EU officials have started talking of vaccinating developing countries before Germany even had 5% of its doses administered; very few places in the EU are anywhere near the maturity of their vaccine rollout where this kind of discussion has a chance of attracting anything besides irritation among voters. And unlike the US, we don't have a second-choice vaccine that we know for sure we cannot use. If I was in the US and knew that it's just a matter of money, I'd be more sympathetic to sharing around.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts