Insight

Share this post

It's not subtle

www.theinsight.org

It's not subtle

When the performative turns into complete indifference

zeynep
Aug 18, 2021
111
12
Share this post

It's not subtle

www.theinsight.org

Some things aren’t subtle. 

Like how we celebrated that Afghan girl robotics team over the years.

They traveled abroad many times, making friends and getting headlines.

Twitter avatar for @apartovi
Ali Partovi @apartovi
It’s been 4 yrs since the Afghan Girls Robotics team visited us at @neo. I’ve been thinking about these inspiring young women. I wonder where they are, whether they’re afraid or need help, and how many others like them are struggling with an uncertain future. ❤️
Image
3:52 PM ∙ Aug 17, 2021
280Likes25Retweets

Even when the blanket ban on people from many Muslim countries was in place, Trump personally intervened to allow them to travel to the United States—though their visas remain rejected.

The U.S. won't say why the girls were rejected for visas, citing confidentiality. But Mohib said that based on discussions with U.S. officials, it appears the girls were rebuffed due to concerns they would not return to Afghanistan. It's a fate that has beset many Afghans seeking entry to the U.S. in recent years as continuing violence and economic challenges lead many to seek asylum in America, or to travel through the U.S. to Canada to try to resettle there.

As their case gained attention, Trump intervened by asking National Security Council officials to find a way for them to travel, officials said. Ultimately the State Department, which adjudicates visa applications, asked the Homeland Security Department to let them in on "parole," a temporary status used only in exceptional circumstances to let in someone who is otherwise ineligible to enter the country. The U.S. granted parole after determining that it constituted a "significant public benefit."

We painted a mural of them on the public facing outer walls of the US embassy in Kabul.

Paula Bronstein/Getty Images

They met with prime ministers. 

Twitter avatar for @CanadianPM
CanadianPM @CanadianPM
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets with The Afghan Dreamers team in Ottawa before they participate in @CANFIRST Robotics Competitions in Toronto and North Bay, Ontario. #girlsinSTEM
Image
8:41 PM ∙ Feb 28, 2018
355Likes100Retweets

And now, they’re trapped in Herat.

Their advocates have been begging for help, so far to no avail.

Twitter avatar for @KimMotleysLaw
Kimberley Motley - Views expressed I own :-) @KimMotleysLaw
Canada asking 4 your help 4 the Afghan Girls Robotics Team! Pls let them come 2 Canada & have a future. Every. Single. Girl. In Afghanistan deserves to be free. Pls help these girls! Citizens contact Canada officials!!! @NatashaFatah @JustinTrudeau @Cifile_Canada #savethegirls
Image
11:51 PM ∙ Aug 15, 2021
28Likes14Retweets
Twitter avatar for @Mikeggibbs
Mike Gibbs🏳️‍🌈 @Mikeggibbs
A lawyer for the Afghan Girls Robotics Team is begging Justin Trudeau to allow Afghan girls to come to Canada so they can continue studying. "If they stay in Afghanistan they will become brides."
Image
Image
Image
1:28 PM ∙ Aug 15, 2021
393Likes115Retweets

Some can’t even be reached anymore.

Twitter avatar for @PositiveSolace
Positive Solace @PositiveSolace
We spoke to @RoyaMahboob & 'The Afghan Dreamers', award winners for their work in robotics a few months ago. She expressed concerns for #Afghanistan with the US troops leaving. In view of recent events, we tried to contact Roya but were unsuccessful.We pray for everyone's safety.
1:16 PM ∙ Aug 18, 2021
5Likes4Retweets

Before anyone says it: yes, of course, they were always treated as symbols. They were tokenized, and turned into convenient feel good stories which got recycled around our buzzwords and concerns. 

When the pandemic hit, they got publicity for working on a low-cost ventilator. 

Twitter avatar for @the_female_lead
The Female Lead @the_female_lead
"The all-female Afghan Robotics Team, which has won international awards for its robots, started work on an open-source, low-cost ventilator as the coronavirus pandemic hit the war-torn nation." Read their story 👇 #iwed2021 reuters.com/article/us-hea…
reuters.comAfghan all-girls robotics team designs low-cost ventilator to treat coronavirus patientsIn the eastern Afghan city of Herat, 18-year-old high school student Somaya Faruqi adjusts a suction cap as she puts the finishing touches before unveiling a low-cost, lightweight ventilator created by her and six other young women.
11:37 PM ∙ Jun 23, 2021
156Likes28Retweets

Before it was their robotics work. They were the counterpart to those viral Boston Dynamics videos, I suppose.

Feel bad, feel good, keep scrolling.

No doubt they were smart and hard-working, like many other girls around the world, and also no doubt they deserved basic rights even if they were just ordinary kids. 

And no, saving them—just about 20 girls—will not magically solve Afghanistan’s problems, which do not lend themselves to easy or wishful thinking. 

As I wrote in my last post, I did not think military intervention in Iraq or Afghanistan was a good idea.

I don’t mean why didn’t we stay longer. I was deeply opposed to our occupation of Iraq and also Afghanistan, not because I’ve any delusions about what’s going on there anyway, but because it’s clear that any prolonged US military presence would make things worse in both places because that’s what military occupations by superior foreign powers do.

What I mean [is that] we didn’t do the minimally decent thing to help get a few of these people out of the country by putting them on planes for the preceding many months during which we could have done easily this—it would have been slightly politically inconvenient because nobody wants them is the honest truth.

I know the reality of global politics. It’s August and this could all easily be forgotten in US domestic politics in about a month as well (after a short news cycle around the 20th anniversary of the 9/11 tragedy).

As an immigrant myself, I’ll go first and concede that immigration is a difficult process, and those “refugees welcome” signs one sees in many liberal neighborhoods are not worth that much in reality. 

Mass migration at scale is a very very fraught process, and even with a lot of resources and goodwill, it can be destabilizing and difficult for everyone touched by it, even if, at times, it is an option of last resort. 

Still, there are things worse than a world of superficial and performative caring: it’s dropping even the pretense of it, even for that few, even after that much publicity before.

As I said, some things aren’t subtle.

12
Share this post

It's not subtle

www.theinsight.org
12 Comments
BB
Aug 18, 2021

The idea of a meritocratic version of migration always bothered me. Like when Trump called developing nations "shithole countries," a quick defense was "hey, a lot of app developers immigrated from these countries!"

As if the mean words are the issue, and not the cruel exclusionary policies that have us ranking people by how much they "deserve" to come to the US based on their ability to make other people money.

The Afghan Robotics team was a similar issue. Of course they deserve to be celebrated for their accomplishments, but holding them up as the "good ones" and focusing specifically on their fate so that we can feel better about ourselves always rubbed me the wrong way.

Then again, if the alternative is to just ignore *everyone* including them, I suppose tokenism is the lesser of two evils.

Expand full comment
Reply
Mary Moss
Aug 18, 2021

Thank you for writing this piece. One of my acquaintances worked with Afghani women. She is in tears. I am in tears. And I am angry. When I looked at the picture of all the Afghani people packed into the military jet that took off, I saw only a few women and children in the picture. Women are at most risk here. Why weren’t they the ones on this plane? Because caring about the plight of Afghani women and children has never really mattered to politicians. Power brokers ignored it before we invaded Afghanistan, used it to win propaganda points during the occupation, and ignore it again now that we have left. I have no doubt the plight of these women will be used as propaganda talking points by the West when it becomes convenient to do so.

Expand full comment
Reply
10 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 zeynep tufekci
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing